We all know a kid sometime in our past who had all the talent in the world, but never made it. It could’ve been due to many different circumstances like money for college, more important responsibility at home, couldn’t stay out of trouble and so on. It still doesn’t change the fact that sometimes people just miss out.
In terms of the NFL, you have to add in the fact that every scouting department isn’t created equally and even if they were, they don’t make the choices. The ones choosing could be sold on someone who is just terrible compared to other guys, but there’s nothing we can do about it. The only things we can do is hedge those decisions for fantasy, which is what I’m here to help you do.
When dealing with fantasy football we like to have guys who have a huge opportunity share in the offense (or defense with IDP leagues). History shows we have to be the same with our rookie drafts.
Here’s why you should, for the most part, avoid guys (with your high picks) drafted in the 6-7 rounds and undrafted free agent pools:
In last 10 years, here are some of the hits for 6-7 rounders and UDFAs. From a recent conversation I had, I decided to change it from an all inclusive 100 PPR points or 6.25 ppg, to position specific. My baseline for success for each position was someone you’d be flexing or starting in most leagues.
Quarterbacks (3 year average of the QB24 = 184 points)
7 QBs have had success in rounds 6-7 with only 4 out of the 7 having done it more than once:
Tom Brady, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Tyrod Taylor and Matt Cassel
The UDFA to accomplish this feat:
Tony Romo, Case Keenum and Kurt Warner.
Wide Receivers (3 year average of the WR36 = 166 points)
6 receivers have done it with only 4 out of 6 having done it more than once:
Antonio Brown, Julian Edelman, Pierre Garcon & Steve Johnson.
20 UDFAs did it with just 9 of them doing it more than once. The most notable:
Wes Welker, Doug Baldwin, Victor Cruz, Adam Thielen, and Willie Snead
Michelle Magdziuk @BallBLastEm made a great observation that cannot be over looked:
Running Backs (3 year average of the RB36 = 134 points)
9 running backs were a RB36 or better and only 6 of them did it more than once:
Rashad Jennings, Alfred Morris, Latavius Murray, Theo Riddick, Andre Ellington, and Justin Forsett
The undrafted accomplished this 22 times with 12 having continued success:
Fred Jackson, Isaiah Crowell, Adrian Foster, Pierre Thomas, Danny Woodhead, C.J. Anderson, Joique Bell, LeGarette Blount, Chris Ivory, Ryan Grant, BenJarvus Green-Ellis, and Mike Tolbert
Tight Ends (3 year average of the TE24 = 93 points)
The TEs that have done it:
Charles Clay, Zach Miller, Brandon Myers, Mychal Rivera, and Ryan Griffin
The only undrafted free agents to do it:
Antonio Gates, Cameron Brate, Jack Doyle, Will Tye, Jake Ballard, Trey Burton, Larry Donnell, and Tim Wright
It’s simple, if the TEAM invests in them, WE have to invest accordingly. The caveat here is that you don’t forget about the late round/UDFA guys.
Allen Iverson’s Law: Talkin’ Bout Practice
One of the best practices is the utilization of your local taxi squad IF you have the room or regular roster if you have the spots. If through the draft process, you found a guy or guys whom you’ve just become enamored with, GO GET THEM. Don’t be dissuaded from getting your guys, just utilize your own draft capital for guys with true draft capital. This is because on average, for every position except quarterback, 1-2 guys per year emerge from that murky junkyard of 6-7 rounders and undrafted free agents to become PPR relevant at least once. Some of these guys end up with long term success, A LOT don’t.
A Rule of Thumb:
There is a much bigger area for “boom-bust” in 6-7/udfa areas than rounds 1-5.
Which is why I believe that these guys are sometimes better served for waivers later on. If they don’t end up free agents in your league, it’s ok. Let someone hold onto your asset for you until it’s time to obtain. Once that player starts tracking for success, you have to act before the price raises or otherwise you over pay in a trade vs making that asset a throw in for an otherwise “underwhelming” trade in the eyes of everyone but you. It’s all about timing. The trick is to not go in to negotiations showing your hand and you’ll be just fine.
Another good practice is to grab these guys when an injury happens to guys ahead of them on the depth chart. This is generally a key time where they can begin to be able to garner more snap counts (time on the field) if they perform well enough.
My pinned thread from Twitter and this article are just a warm-up for a series of articles and rankings so, be on the lookout for those, which will come directly after this.
A small hint to my ranking content-they will be different than you’ve seen before! Hopefully this has helped you prepare for your rookie drafts, stay tuned!